Skip to content

Friday, Nov 21st 2008


July 31st Afternoon: The Recession Diaries

a0_boo.JPGDid anyone catch the curious symmetry? On the day that unemployment, once again, shot up, AIB announced their half-yearly profits. Two different worlds on this small island.

Not that there weren’t attempts to show that these different worlds are experiencing the same thing. The Irish Times headlines: AIB Profits Fall. And the Irish Independent has it: AIB Set for First Earnings Fall in 17 years. Yes, there was that. But let’s put this into context. AIB’s profits for the first half of the year was €1.28 billion. This compared to profits of €1.32 billion in the first half of last year. A fall but only by a fraction - and given the changed financial landscape it’s hardly a fall worth mentioning.

Of course, AIB senior executives had to make a finely nuanced presentation - suggesting difficult times ahead while saying nothing that would frighten the investors. Hence, the dividend increase which fed into growing investor confidence (shares bounced after the announcement). And the get tough line on expenditure - job losses (which were not really job losses but rather postponement of job replacements). A rise in ‘criticised’ loans - loans which require increased scrutiny - but hardly any arrears from the 100% mortgages on their books. If it was all a bit of smoke and mirrors, a bit of this and a bit of that, the bottom line remained - AIB is making a hell of a profit and the great taxpayer bail-out is being set up.

What’s that? There are suggestions that the banks (or some of them) are preparing to ask the Government (that is, the taxpayer) to secure loans. Essentially, the public is being asked to give the banks a guarantee for activity that they should be doing anyway - lending money. This is of a piece: when Bears went belly-up in the States, the Federal Reserve essentially guaranteed their dodgy asset book to facilitate a buy-out by JP Morgan (without the guarantee, Bears would probably have sunk bringing a ton of people with it). Nice for JP Morgan who picked up shares in Bears for a rock-bottom price. Likewise, UK banks have been lining up outside the Bank of England looking for similar public subsidies. It’s the old ‘privatise profits, socialise losses’ gambit.

There are no smoke and mirrors when it comes to unemployment, though. While there are some slight quibbles as to the actual percentage out of work (is it 5.9% or 5.8% or 5.7% when seasonality is finally factored in?), the fact remains: between January and May, the numbers signing on increased by an average of 5,000 per month; in the last two months that average has doubled to 10,000.

And whereas at the beginning of the year, it was mostly males in the queue (71 percent), in the last two months the majority of new signings on have been women. All this suggesting that the construction decline has well and truly made it into other sectors of the economy.

And what do the unemployed get? Unemployment payments well below the relative poverty line, Minister Hanafin putting them through a number of hoops just to get an insurance payment they have paid into, and little prospect of getting back into the workforce as the decline accelerates. And this comes with a hefty price-tag to the taxpayers - €690 million by some estimates.

Still, be grateful for small mercies. AIB maintain their profits, their shareholders get a higher dividend, share prices increase and, if they play their cards right, they’ll get a big fat subsidy down the line from a Government who jumps everytime the financiers say ‘boo’. Again, paid for by the same taxpayers who are footing the jobless bill (and the real hoot is that some of those taxpayers are the unemployed). All that with no hoops to jump through.

God, you just gotta love capitalism.

Discussion

We welcome and encourage lively discussion from the public about articles on Irish Left Review. You can leave a comment using the form at the bottom of the page. Please read through the existing comments before posting your own.

No comments so far

Leave a Comment

(required)

(required, will not be published)

Subscribe to ILR

ILR Full Content Feed

Latest Links

  • The Oil Crunch | Business | The Guardian

    "The energy watchdog, the International Energy Agency, is warning for the first time that oil output could pass its peak as power shifts from "super-majors" to national companies controlled by producer states. It highlights a potential oil-supply crunch. The unprecedented wake-up call comes as the European commission says in a report due out tomorrow that while oilfields decline, the balance of supply and demand will become "increasingly tight, possibly critically so"."

    It adds: "The need to address climate change will require a massive switch to high-efficiency, low-carbon energy technologies."

    No comments »
  • Gavyn Davies: Deflation is now a more serious threat than inflation |

    Yet another thoughtful piece which shows just how adrift mainstream political and economic thinking in Ireland is from the ideas being touted to deal with our unprecedented economic crisis. Davies advocates PRINTING MORE MONEY. And cites the chair of the US Federal Reserve to back him up. How about it Mr. Lenihan?

    No comments »
  • The Iraq Math War

    This Mother Jones article tells the story of Les Roberts and Gilbert Burnham whose Iraq Mortality Survey was published in the Lancet in 2004. The article notes that since the White House slammed it as 'junk' despite approving of other Roberts and Burnham mortality surveys which used the same methods in Kosovo and elsewhere the survey continues to be labelled as 'controversal'.

    No comments »
  • James Wood: Victory Speech

    James Wood waxing lyrical about Obama's victory speech; 'a good night out for the English language.'

    No comments »
  • What a Long, Strange Trip It’s Been

    Bill Ayers' account of his cameo role in the US elections just past. It tallies pretty accurately with Obama's.

    No comments »
  • Mike Davis | Casino Capitalism, Obama, and Us

    "Let me confess that, as an aging socialist, I suddenly find myself like the Jehovah's Witness who opens his window to see the stars actually falling out of the sky. Although I've been studying Marxist crisis theory for decades, I never believed I'd actually live to see financial capitalism commit suicide. Or hear the International Monetary Fund warn of imminent "systemic meltdown." "

    No comments »
  • The American Void: Simon Critchley | Harper’s Magazine

    We must believe, but we can’t believe. Perhaps this is the tragedy that some of us see in Obama: a change we can believe in and the crushing realization that nothing will change.

    No comments »
  • Rick Wolff, “Policies to “Avoid” Economic Crises”

    While conservative and liberal policies do little to solve crises, the debate between them has largely succeeded in excluding anti-capitalist analyses of economic crises from public discussion.

    No comments »
  • America the Liberal

    John Judis argues that 2008 may mark an historic leftward realignment in America, akin to 1930 and 1896, that could pave the way for an enduring Democratic majority over the next several decades. Will the Obama presidency seize the moment?

    No comments »
  • New Left Review - David Harvey: The Right to the City

    Read this while Stevie Wonder's 'Living in the City' is playing in the background

    "We live in an era when ideals of human rights have moved centre stage both politically and ethically. A great deal of energy is expended in promoting their significance for the construction of a better world. But for the most part the concepts circulating do not fundamentally challenge hegemonic liberal and neoliberal market logics, or the dominant modes of legality and state action. We live, after all, in a world in which the rights of private property and the profit rate trump all other notions of rights. I here want to explore another type of human right, that of the right to the city."

    No comments »

Links Archives »