Skip to content

Wednesday, Jan 7th 2009


It Ain’t Over ’Til It’s Over

Well, it’s been a busy few weeks trying to keep up with the US Presidential election campaign and the global economic crisis, to say nothing of trying to do some work occasionally.So, inevitably, the campaign is taking place in the shadow of ‘events’ and has been affected by them. As we move into the final two weeks, things are looking good for Obama. He’s gained the endorsement of Colin Powell and done well out of the Joe the Plumber episode, although ‘spread the wealth around‘ was rather a high risk statement in the US context. The choice of Sarah Palin as VP candidate is starting to backfire badly and is being used against McCain as an error of judgement, for example by Powell when he endorsed Obama.

The polls are looking OK but not brilliant. The Real Clear Politics poll average is now Obama 49.2% and McCain 43.7%, given Obama a lead of 5.5%. More importantly, in the states targeted by McCain - Florida, North Carolina and Virginia - Obama is leading by 3.2%, 1.3% and 8.1% respectively. Anyone who has experience of fighting elections knows this isn’t enough to be sure of victory. The Obama campaign is very aware of the danger of complacency and has been working hard on voter registration and to get the vote out; in addition, there’s always a question about the accuracy of polls, and in this campaign it’s about race. Quite rightly, nothing is being taken for granted. The Washington Post thinks the next priority should be for Obama to communicate exactly how he would lead:

Over the next two weeks, Obama should help the country visualize what his administration would look like. He should show how he would step up to the economic crisis, an unfolding disaster that we compare so often to the Great Depression that the analogy is losing its horrific impact. What sorts of people would Obama appoint to his Cabinet? How would he deal with two wars, as commander in chief rather than as political campaigner?

In other words, forget about McCain, it’s all about you, Obama.

So how will we remember the 2008 campaign?

The one that took place during a financial crisis

Obama’s nomination speech on August 29th seems a very long time ago now. Then, it seemed obvious that the next two months would be dominated by the campaign. But that was before Fanny Mae and Freddy Mac, the Lehman Brothers collapse, the banks bailout that wasn’t supported, then the one that was, and continuing economic bad news around the world. Economic issues sidelined the campaign at times and contextualised it for the voters (and the rest of us) in a way that rarely happens in elections - next year, the guy who wins will be the one addressing the nation on all this, folks. Both candidates’ economic policies gained an extra edge from the urgency of the situation. Obama came out of it well: decisive, calm, and Presidential looking. McCain was stuck between the impetus to do something and his dislike of further state intervention.

The one where the smears didn’t quite come off

Palling around with terrorists, being a Muslim (and so what if he had been?), being too black, too old, too corrupt, having too large a family to look after, not having enough experience, not having the right kind of experience, not having suffered enough in Vietnam, not defending the environment…

There have been smears in this campaign, but they haven’t done the damage. It’s been remarkably focused on the issues: candidates have suffered, not through the traded insults, but if they’ve given the impression that they are indecisive, lack credible policies or, in the case of Sarah Palin, can’t give a comprehensible answer. At different times, both campaigns have been urged to be tougher on their opponents but have not done so. Of course there’s an element of negativity out there, but both campaigns have done well to keep it under control.

The one where there actually were policy differences

The presidential and vice-presidential candidates’ debates failed to reach inspirational heights, but there are real differences between the candidates which ought to make it easy for Americans to choose. Take the economy and foreign policy. Each candidate has been forced to clarify their policies on the economy due to the current situation and they have defended their proposals face to face. McCain still believes in the trickle down theory; Obama wants to cut taxes for those on lower incomes, and create jobs through public sector works programmes. Obama is saying some people can afford to pay a little more tax, which in US terms is very radical indeed. Regarding foreign policy, the message is watch Pakistan if Obama wins - he may disagree with the war in Iraq, but he’s no pacifist.

But in some cases you can never do enough.

The one with the bimbo and the amazing  wife

The role of women in the campaign has been prominent since the time when it was assumed that Hillary Clinton would be the Democrats’ nominee. The highest profile women have been Sarah Palin and Michelle Obama, but Hillary’s putative votes have remained hovering in the background, and let’s not forget the women policy advisers, interviewers, satirists and bloggers who have pitched in this time around.

The choice of Sarah Palin as Republican VP candidate must rank as the biggest screw-up of the campaign. It would be easy to say ‘what were they thinking of?’, but we all know. It was a cynical attempt to get votes from women, including Clinton supporters. And for the men, she’s good-looking too. The initial concerns were about the strange mix of her rabidly right-wing opinions and large areas of ignorance; but this is now solidifying into a view that, given McCain’s age and potential health problems, she is a completely inappropriate choice for a potential President.

Michelle Obama, on the other hand, has been winning hearts wherever she goes. What a woman. And a tactical strength to the campaign as she emphasises the Obamas’ stable family life and sense of values, including their (Christian) religious beliefs and practices. Watch here how she never, ever, loses it. You might be able to be a Black President, but I don’t think I’ll see the day when a single man or woman makes it.

The one we could laugh at

And the world was introduced to the Daily Show and Saturday Night Live. My life wasn’t complete until I discovered Jon Stewart and Tina Fey. But why was there so much to laugh at? Americans aren’t famous for satire, but how could you not send up some aspects of this campaign? Funny, clever and pro-Democrat, Obama should give them a job.

So finally, and hopefully, this election will be…

The one which elected the first African American President of the United States.

But there are another two weeks to go, and it’s by no means certain yet.

Discussion

We welcome and encourage lively discussion from the public about articles on Irish Left Review. You can leave a comment using the form at the bottom of the page. Please read through the existing comments before posting your own.

No comments so far

Leave a Comment

(required)

(required, will not be published)

Subscribe to ILR

ILR Full Content Feed

Latest Links

  • Saree Makdisi |”By choice they made themselves immune”

    Israel has killed and injured almost 4,000 men, women and children so far in its assault on Gaza; it has entombed whole families together in the ruins of their homes. As I write, news is breaking that Israeli bombs have killed at least 40 civilians huddling in a UN school which they mistakenly thought would be safer than the homes from which Israel's relentless barrage — and its deliberately terrorizing "warning" leaflets and prerecorded phone calls — had already driven them. (I still have one of the leaflets the Israelis dropped on besieged Beirut in 1982 and the language is exactly the same — "flee, flee for your lives!"). Mosques, schools, houses, apartment buildings, have all been brought down on the heads of those inside.

    No comments »
  • Avi Shlaim |How Israel brought Gaza to the brink of humanitarian catastrophe | The Guardian

    A rogue state habitually violates international law, possesses weapons of mass destruction and practises terrorism - the use of violence against civilians for political purposes. Israel fulfils all of these three criteria; the cap fits and it must wear it. Israel’s real aim is not peaceful coexistence with its Palestinian neighbours but military domination.

    No comments »
  • LRB | Sara Roy: If Gaza falls . . .

    Sara Roy provides lots of detail about how Israel wants the world to see Gaza as a place populated beggers trapped in a war zone and not a civilised people trying to live independently in a viable state.
    “Israel’s siege of Gaza began on 5 November, the day after an Israeli attack inside the strip, no doubt designed finally to undermine the truce between Israel and Hamas established last June. Although both sides had violated the agreement before, this incursion was on a different scale. Hamas responded by firing rockets into Israel and the violence has not abated since then. Israel’s siege has two fundamental goals. One is to ensure that the Palestinians there are seen merely as a humanitarian problem, beggars who have no political identity and therefore can have no political claims. The second is to foist Gaza onto Egypt. That is why the Israelis tolerate the hundreds of tunnels between Gaza and Egypt around which an informal but increasingly regulated commercial sector has begun to form. The overwhelming majority of Gazans are impoverished and officially 49.1 per cent are unemployed.”

    No comments »
  • Mass uprising of Greece’s youth, by Valia Kaimaki

    Why did Greek youth take to the streets? Kaimaki asks. Because, he says, for 'the first time since the second world war young people have no hope of a better life than their parents. But there is also a failure of trust in politicians and all state institutions, particularly the police'.

    But the political movement known as the 700 euro generation, which is supported by 60% of the population, is now being exported or finding convergence elsewhere. The reason? Simply because the existence of a young generation who do not have the prospects of a better life than their parents is not unique to Greece.

    No comments »
  • The Irish Economy’s Rise Was Steep, and the Fall Was Fast - NYTimes.com

    "Irish banks, unlike those in the United States, didn’t dole out that many subprime loans. Rather, they lent furiously to big property developers who themselves were liberated to build pell-mell by government-imposed tax breaks." The New York Times on Ireland's property bust

    No comments »
  • Joseph Massad: The Gaza Ghetto Uprising

    Since 2006, Arab regimes, neoliberal Arab intellectuals, as well as the Palestinian Collaborationist Authority (PCA) in Ramallah have reached an understanding that only Israel will be able to save them from Hizballah and Hamas, both organizations constituting a threat to the open alliance Arab regimes have with the US and Israel against Iran and all progressive forces in the region. These were not closely guarded secret hopes, but strategies that were openly discussed in private meetings, which often spilled into the public realm. […] A veritable open alliance now exists between the Palestinian Collaborationist Authority, Arab regimes, and Israel with the support of neoliberal Arab intellectuals, wherein Israel is subcontracted to decimate the Hamas government — the only democratically elected government in the entire Arab world.

    No comments »
  • Norman Finkelstein | Israel seeking Arab obeisance

    Finkelstein says that getting rid of Hamas in Gaza is not the objective of the current conflict. Instead it is to show the international community, including Iran that it will not accept a two-state settlement. It wants to be able to continue its control of the West Bank.
    "Finkelstein: The Hamas leadership in recent years has signaled that it is willing to negotiate a two-state settlement according to the June 1967 border and also the resolution of the refugee question. That means that Hamas has signaled to do what the international community has wanted Israel to do over the past 30 years.
    Israel rejects such a two-state settlement because it wants to continue its control of the West Bank. So for Israel a moderate Palestinian means the one who rejects all the terms proposed by the international community, a Palestinian who rejects the position of Hamas. For Israel a moderate Palestinian is a Palestinian who is willing to do whatever Israel wants. "

    No comments »
  • YouTube - Rocky Road To Dublin Peter Lennon Documentary

    Peter Lennon's 1967 documentary that was effectively banned for decades from RTE. An angry exposé of the stifling de facto theocracy then in place, it competed at Cannes in 1968 but was denied a prize when Godard and Truffaut's protest led to the festival being suspended. Godard's regular director of photography Raoul Coutard shot the film. Lennon was also a close friend of Samuel Beckett.

    No comments »
  • Steve Early | Is Obama Backing Off a Crucial Pledge to Labor? Bait and Switch on the Employee Free Choice Act”

    "While running for office, Obama said he strongly backed the Employee Free Choice Act (EFCA), a long overdue labor law reform measure that should be part of his promised economic stimulus plan. However, when Obama introduced his top economic advisors on Nov. 25 and talked about steps to "jolt" the economy in January, EFCA was not part of the package. More disturbingly, his new chief of staff, Rahm Emanuel, declined to say whether the White House would support EFCA when he was questioned about it at a Wall Street Journal-sponsored "CEO Council" earlier in November."

    No comments »
  • red mum | Facebook organised vigil tomorrow: Wednesday, Dec 10

    If you are in Dublin on Wednesday, December 10th at 6.30pm please come along to Dail Eireann where a candlelit vigil (part of the ongoing campaign calling on Harney to reinstate the HPV vaccine) is taking place. If you are in Cork on Wednesday at 6.30pm the vigil will be taking place at Daunts Square. More details here: http://redmum.blogspot.com/2008/12/facebook-organised-vigil-happening-next.html

    No comments »

Links Archives »