
Irish Left Review Is One Year Old
As Garibaldi on Cedar Lounge Revolution has already mentioned, the Sunday Independent contains a unique:
… mixture of arrogance, snobbery, hysteria, ineptitude, and desperation to appear oh so metropolitan and sophisticated while remaining unremittingly provincial.
Like all Irish newspapers it is virulently pro-business, doggedly centre right and socially conservative. However, unlike the Irish Times with its ‘senior civil servant’ haughtiness, or even the slightly more restrained shop-keeper friendly Irish Independent, it’s doesn’t even try to hide its partisan agenda. Columnist, Senator, and rightwing apparatchik Eoghan Harris, on one of his jousts on the Late Late Show recently referred to the paper as a broad church. But apart from the singular ‘leftwing’ voice of Gene Kerrigan the vast majority of commentators, Harris included, make their overtly right-wing political points with the subtly and honesty of a cheap used-car sales man.
Yesterday’s paper provided the best example. Here’s Jody Corcoran’s ‘analysis’ on the current political situation:
The future, then, is socialism, or so it would seem: not the woolly socialism of David Begg and his beloved Scandinavian model, but the unreconstructed socialism of Jack O’Connor and his cabal. Do not say you have not been warned.
It is time then for Irish Left Review to shut up shop. Is our job done?
But wait, Jody is only kicking the tires at this point, for he continues:
The momentum is currently with this well-organised band of former communists and socialists who have been licking their wounds for almost 20 years, since the collapse of the Soviet Union and the totalitarian regimes of Eastern Europe.
Analyzing Irish politics may be like making love to a beautiful woman, but from Jody’s point of view it’s probably best to scare the bejesus out of them first, and it seems that there is nothing scarier to the Sunday Independent reader - one imagines them reading Jody’s bilge after Mass while waiting for the Sunday chicken to roast - than socialism.
With this sudden dominance of Irish socialism, at least in Jody’s imagination, it is a good time to reflect on the first year of Irish Left Review, especially as we could be seen as a vanguard element which may be only marginally involved in its sudden spectacular success.
ILR was set up last February, with the inaugural post by Conor McCabe going up on the 21st (I realize I’m a week late here). Conor’s essay: Michael Zweig, Class, Consumerism and Ireland is worth reading again in the light of all that has happened in Irish political life in the last 12 months. Before the last election we were treated to the idea that we are all middle-class now, a notion that was very much supported by Independent Newspapers among others. Now, in the series of polls, from Lisbon and through the recent ones indicating the meltdown of Fianna Fail dominance, we hear much about that ‘silent majority’, to quote Zweig, called the ‘working class’ - the quotation marks are necessary because the media categorization is based solely on one developed for newspapers and magazines (ABC1s etc) which are used to figure out the social profile and earnings of their audience for advertising purposes - and we see the anger of working people as they protest and plan strikes against the stripping away of their jobs and relatively modest livelihood by a government that lavished the greatest gains of the ‘boom’ on the banking and business class that supported them.
Another early essay that remains relevant in the current circumstances is Michael Taft’s essay Don’t Sing the Half Party Blues which starts off with a description of an imagined Breaking News items reporting on Labour’s substantial gains after the 2009 Local Elections:
Breaking News - Press Association (1 Hour ago) Gilmore claims victory in Irish local elections. The Leader of the Irish Labour Party claimed victory in Ireland’s local election. Speaking at a press conference with the leaders of Sinn Fein and the Green Party, he called yesterday’s result a ‘breakthrough not only for the parties involved in the Common Cause, but for all people who want an alternative to the discredited politics of the civil war parties’. The Common Cause - a loose arrangement between the Labour Party, Sinn Fein and the Green Party - caused a major upset by getting more votes than either the two larger parties, Fianna Fail and Fine Gael (see more)
Now it seems with Labour gains in the polls, the constant revelations around Anglo Irish Bank and the well known connections between Fianna Fail and that bank, that it could well be after a national rather than a local election that Gilmore is speaking of such an alliance - although so far Labour has dismissing the idea.
What characterized the early months of Irish Left Review, as we found our feet, was the quality of the monthly essays, each of which focused on a specific policy area were a common ground could be established between the progressive parties. So we had an excellent essay by Alex Klemm on Criminal Justice, Something Must Be Done, which illustrated how each of the parties had a lot of in common when it came to that issue, and another on how the environment is a socialist issue by Damian O’Brion, which argued for the implementing of personal carbon credits, a scheme considerably more equitable than the now almost inevitably introduction of a carbon tax.
There was also an attempt to be more timely. On the 1st of May we published an essay by Seanachie of Pleasures of Underachievement simply called ‘1968‘, and in July were had a number of lengthy articles on the fall out from the Irish No vote against the Lisbon Treaty - the review essay by Chekov Feeney stands as perhaps the best analysis of the campaign and result done anywhere.
We also dealt with specific issues. A series of articles by Dr. Gerry Burke, a consultant obstetrician & gynaecologist in Limerick’s Regional and Maternity Hospitals criticized co-location and highlighted the appalling state of Ireland’s maternity services. He also provided a critique of the 2009 budget and Mary Harney’s decision to remove medical card eligibility for the over 70s in an attempt to balance the budget while retaining co-location.
Mary Mulholland wrote a great article on the current drive within the Irish Gay & Lesbian community to tie equality rights for gays and lesbians to the institution of marriage.
We have also dealt with the media in thorough way, interviewing the author of several academic papers on media bias and contributor to How Ireland Voted 2007, Dr. Heinz Brandenburg and a critique on the involvement of Irish newspapers in the inflating of Ireland’s property bubble.
But it is in the area of the economy that I would hope that we have provided the most food for thought. Michael Taft in his ‘put up or shut up’ essay: Towards a New Economic Narrative sketched out a number of possible solutions to the increasingly dire economic situation that Ireland currently faces.
The economy, which had been over reliant on the short term benefits of a speculative financial and property bubble is now contracting rapidly. Michael argued that rather than cutting budgets and increasing taxes, which would put further deflationary pressure on the economy that we should try to expand the economy. In a counter cyclical maneuver we should try to take measures to grow rather than deflate the economy.
The objective for Irish Left Review was to try and engage with others to see if they agreed or disagreed with Michael’s analysis. The result were pieces from Dan Boyle of the Green Party, Professor Terrence McDonough of NUI, Galway, Stephen Kinsella, from UL and Kieran Allen, of UCD and SWP .
Professor McDonough has also written a recent piece on the need to nationalize our banks, now.
There is more, so much more. This is not even the half of it. Perhaps I’ll update this post later.
Discussion
We welcome and encourage lively discussion from the public about articles on Irish Left Review. You can leave a comment using the form at the bottom of the page. Please read through the existing comments before posting your own.

Comment by: Dermot Looney
Mar 3rd 2009 at 00:03
Congrats to all involved on the fantastic resource which has been developed this past 12 months.
It’s a must read for anyone on the Irish left. Keep up the good work.
Adelante!
Comment by: Conor McCabe
Mar 3rd 2009 at 01:03
Dermot, I’d love to run with the idea of “all involved” but as “all involved” with Irish Left Review know, there wouldn’t be an Irish Left Review without Donagh. he’s pretty much the “all involved” you’re referring to.
Comment by: donagh
Mar 3rd 2009 at 10:03
Thanks Dermot, glad to know someone appreciates it.
Thanks too, Conor, for letting the cat out of the bag. But I don’t think its true. Although I have done much of the hassling, the list of contributors on the side illustrates that Irish Left Review has involved the effort of a lot of people, whether they are writing articles or interviewing people, or helping out on the practical side. You’ve done an awful lot yourself. If Irish Left Review is any good it is down to the work of the contributors.
I have thanked everyone individually, but it’s worth acknowledging that effort in a public way.
Comment by: Conor McCabe
Mar 3rd 2009 at 10:03
Yeah but you can take any one of us out of the picture and the site would continue. Take you away from the site and it was collapse. That’s just the way it is.
Comment by: donagh
Mar 3rd 2009 at 12:03
Better keep it going so.
Comment by: Conor McCabe
Mar 3rd 2009 at 15:03
no pressure, but yeah
Comment by: Niall
Mar 3rd 2009 at 21:03
Congrats guys. When it comes to quality, the ILR has very few competitors.
Comment by: donagh
Mar 4th 2009 at 09:03
Cheers Niall, much appreciated.