
ICTU and TASC launch H.E.A.P. Report on Income Inequality
Today, ICTU and TASC published the Hierarchy of Earnings, Attributes and Privilege report (PDF) or H.E. A.P report, authored by Professor Terrence McDonough of The Dept of Economics, NUI Galway, (see recent ILR podcast interview) and Jason Loughrey. You can find the full press release below. The full report deserves to be studied in detail but its main finding are that contrary to what is commonly understood to be the case, levels of inequality in Ireland are high compared to other EU countries and they actually increased during the ‘Celtic tiger’ years. Of course, now that we are in recession there is a danger that inequality will increase further. As Richard Wilkinson and Kate Pickett’s book The Spirit Level shows (see John Baker’s review of the book for ILR here) increased levels of inequality leads to lower outcomes for all levels of society.
The equality think-tank TASC and the Irish Congress of Trade Unions today launched the Hierarchy of Earnings, Attributes and Privilege (H.E.A.P.) report, designed to present the facts about income inequality in Ireland in an accessible form. The report - which was authored by NUIG academics Professor Terrence McDonough and Jason Loughrey - comprises a poster illustrating the numbers of households at different income levels, broken down by occupational category and household type, together with an explanatory booklet. The press conference was addressed by TASC Director Paula Clancy, Professor Terry McDonough and Congress General Secretary David Begg.
The report shows that:
- Five per cent of families live on incomes exceeding €134,000
- 58 percent of families live on less than €40,000
- 26 percent of families live on less than €20,000
- When analysed in terms of occupation, only the managerial/professional occupation category makes its way to the very top of the H.E.A.P. (an annual income of €600,000)
- Income distribution became more unequal between 1987 and 2005. The distance between those at the top and those at the bottom widened.
- Conventional measures of income inequality, such as the Gini Coefficient or quintile share ratios, fail to capture the increase in inequality
- Relative poverty levels before Social Welfare transfers increased from 35.6 per cent to 41 per cent from 2001 to 2007. Social Welfare played a critical role in reducing poverty levels from 21.9 per cent in 2001 to 16.5 per cent in 2007
- Women’s income was around two-thirds of men’s income; adjusting for differences in hours worked, women’s hourly earnings were around 86 per cent of men’s. Women were also more likely to be at risk of poverty.
- There is a striking ‘education premium‘: the median gross income of those with no formal education, or primary education only, was €13,489, while those with a university degree had a median income of €45,707
Speaking at the launch of the report, Congress General Secretary David Begg said:
“Here we have a graphic illustration of our clearly divided society, and strong evidential support for the view that Government cannot continue to impose the burden of this recession on low and middle income earners. Massive amounts of wealth were generated during the boom years. This report very clearly shows where that money did not go - to the majority of the population. And that wealth has not evaporated; it is still there, albeit concentrated in a few hands. If Government had any intention of forging a new and more equal Ireland out of this mess, it would study this report closely and act decisively to ensure nothing like it could ever be compiled again. We won’t hold our breath”.
TASC director Paula Clancy said:
“We’ve known for some time that income inequality in particular, and economic inequality in general, is rife in Ireland. Now, the H.E.A.P. report enables us to put figures on inequality. And, by breaking incomes down by occupational category and household type, the H.E.A.P. report shows just who gets how much. What is clear is that a very small group of people benefited enormously from the boom: Five per cent of families live on incomes exceeding €134,000 - and that doesn’t take account of wealth holdings. At the same time, nearly 60 per cent of all families live on less than €40,000, and 26 per cent struggle to survive on incomes of less than €20,000. The longest line of icons in the H.E.A.P. chart represents families on around €10,000 annually - not only Social Welfare recipients but low-paid workers.
“Thanks to the groundbreaking research carried out by UK social scientists Richard Wilkinson and Kate Pickett, we know that more unequal societies have poorer outcomes across a variety of indicators, ranging from life expectancy via literacy levels to imprisonment rates. That is why the findings in the H.E.A.P. report are so disturbing and have such serious implications for public policy. TASC is currently working on a number of policy areas with the aim of constructing a roadmap towards ‘recovery with equality’, and the H.E.A.P. report will help inform that work”.
Professor Terrence McDonough of NUIG, who authored the report, said:
“Ireland has long been judged one of the most unequal of the advanced industrial nations. Recent data comparing Ireland to our colleagues in the EU 15 confirms this. Recent years have seen some increase in the income of those at the bottom of our society. Nevertheless recent research has confirmed that while the absolute welfare of those at the bottom is important, the overall level of equality in society matters as well. Many social and health problems are worsened by inequality and levels of trust are damaged. The Celtic Tiger years and the resources generated were not used to reduce inequality. In fact, inequality increased over the life of the Celtic Tiger. Inequality of income between men and women remains an issue. The H.E.A.P. Chart graphically depicts the structure of income inequality among households in Ireland. It also contains information about family structure and the occupations of adult family members. In seeking to address our state deficit crisis, we must be mindful to do it in such a way that inequality is lessened rather than increased. The incomes of those at the bottom must be protected while those at the top must contribute more”.



Discussion
We welcome and encourage lively discussion from the public about articles on Irish Left Review. You can leave a comment using the form at the bottom of the page. Please read through the existing comments before posting your own.

Comment by: Robert McCann
Nov 19th 2009 at 08:11
Now if some one can do another survey to see how this is reported in the mainstream media…including ‘RTE’ and ‘The Star’ news paper…we never hear about these reports on mary wilsons drive time or sean o’rourke news at 1…or maybe its just me??
Comment by: donagh
Nov 19th 2009 at 12:11
Apparently its got quite good coverage. Although in the Independent for example, its just a small piece:
http://www.independent.ie/national-news/many-families-live-on-836420000-as-rich-and-poor-gap-grows-1947886.html
Comment by: Dave
Nov 19th 2009 at 16:11
And all the talk is about cutting social welfare and increasing the tax net for the lower paid. There’s no talk of increasing highest rate of tax or corporation tax slightly (which would generate huge sums), getting rid of tax loopholes or means testing children’s allowance, college fees or pensions. Instead they intend to tax Carbon and increase VAT which is disproportionate in its effects to the families going hungry and in danger of being kicked out onto the street. This is the reality of what’s happening and I think most would want or should want a change of government asap!
Comment by: Terence
Nov 22nd 2009 at 18:11
You can read a lot more about the Spirit Level and the data about the impact of inequality on society at:
http://www.equalitytrust.org.uk