Skip to content

Thursday, Sep 2nd 2010


Joe Deasy: A Life on the Left - An Extract

The following is a short extract from the recently published biography of political activist and former Labour Party Councillor Joe Deasy by Brian Kenny, published in association with the Hugh Geraghty-Crumlin, Drimnagh, Walkinstown Branch of The Labour Party. Details of how to get Joe Deasy: A Life on the Left are at the end of this extract. The audio interview with Joe, recorded prior to the publication of his biography, was originally posted on ILR in November.

Life as a Councillor

Times were tough for many people in post war Ireland, with poor housing and completely inadequate health services. Almost every weekend people were calling to the Deasy family home with the same question ‘Joe, can you get us a house?’ TB was a major public health problem and as Noel Browne wrote in his autobiography “A nearly hysterical fear of tuberculosis was universal. It affected all classes, and as death took a long time and could be painful, this fear was understandable.” Joe regarded the disease as ‘merciless and rampant at the time with a house near us in Goldenbridge losing two young girls’.

The need for decent housing for poor and working families was the key issue which dominated Joe’s five year term with Dublin Corporation. The problem was severe, with the City Manager in 1946 notifying the council that there were 18,000 applicants on the housing waiting list.

Joe raised the issue whenever he could and a few months after his election he spoke at a Corporation meeting of the difficulties newly weds were having in finding affordable houses, noting that “thousands of young men were getting married in Dublin on wages of £2-10s a week and were having to pay 30s and 35s in rent”. Joe’s comments had the support of ‘Big’ Jim Larkin who was also a councillor and chairman of the Housing Committee.

One of the first motions Joe put before the Corporation called on it to record “its sympathy and appreciation of the heroic struggles being waged by the Carndonagh Tenants Association against extortionate landlordism and calls upon the government to introduce legislation to deal with the whole question of ground rents which inflicts so much hardship on the common people….” The fact that Carndonagh was in Donegal didn’t deter the young councillor from raising the issue in the city council chambers.

Other motions and questions on housing issues featured during Joe’s term. In 1948, for example, he pursued the City Manager, to say “when the tenants of Keogh Square can expect to have electric light functioning in their flats”. A year later he raised the same question but still didn’t get a definite answer. Ironically, as far back as 1943 this matter was raised by the Inchicore Branch which had been told by a Corporation official that “estimates for this work were being sought and considered”. The housing situation was so poor that, in 1948, the Corporation took up an offer of a £100,000 loan from the ITGWU for financing capital requirements under the Housing of the Working Classes Acts.

Despite the chronic housing shortage, different rules seemed to apply when the Catholic Church was involved. On one occasion the Corporation’s housing committee received a proposal to allocate two houses to two priests on Clogher Road in Crumlin. Joe was almost a lone voice in opposing the application. He spoke strongly against it and recalls saying that ‘we are driving a coach and four through every rule regarding the allocation of housing in this city’.

As he spoke his party colleague, Barney Conway, kept nudging him saying ‘don’t Joe, just don’t’. The priests got their two houses and when Joe told this story to his parents his father remained quiet but his mother simply said ‘Joe did the right thing’.

The chronic health epidemic caused by TB was also pursued by Joe. In 1947 his motion “expressed grave dissatisfaction with the further serious delay to the provision of a proper TB sanatorium for the people of Dublin”. A report prepared by Joe on the Crooksling TB sanatorium exposed shocking conditions and a meeting of the Corporation’s public health committee was convened to discuss it. The meeting was memorable for Jim Larkin’s contribution where he “nearly lifted the roof off City Hall with a roar of indignation”.

There were, however, also some lighter moments. In February 1946 Larkin proposed and had passed a motion granting the Freedom of the City to George Bernard Shaw, a motion Joe was more than happy to support. With characteristic style Shaw responded that “I shall be gratefully proud to become an honorary freeman of my native city… in spite of my incessantly controversial past and present I have not disgraced her”. (Privately, Shaw had written to Larkin saying he would not have accepted the honour but that the motion was proposed by him). The Corporation were keen for Shaw to attend the ceremony in person but he observed, “I am too old to be present, but there is so little of me left that I will hardly be missed”.

Jim Larkin

Joe served as a councillor alongside Jim Larkin from his election in mid 1945 until Larkin’s untimely death at the end of January 1947. Larkin, an imposing figure, was a ‘domineering man’. As one Fine Gael councillor ruefully remarked to Joe, ‘Larkin gets his own way, all the officials are afraid of him’. Larkin could be rough but also had the sensitivity to want to see the artistic contribution of people like Shaw recognised.

Joe had first hand experience of Larkin’s volatility. At one council meeting he praised Joe as an ‘intelligent young man’, which didn’t stop him from walking out of a subsequent Labour meeting after some remarks the same youthful Joe Deasy had made.

The ‘intelligent young man’ comment followed a letter Joe had published in The Irish Times on the issue of child welfare.

Sean MacEntee, never one to miss an opportunity to criticise Labour, had complained of the delay by Dublin Corporation in responding to his new maternity and child welfare scheme for the city. Joe responded strongly and pointed out that “… it takes Mr MacEntee’s government fourteen years to formulate a scheme of this nature despite the appalling infant mortality rate in Dublin…”. He went on to note that the Corporation’s public health committee had unanimously accepted the principle of the project and strongly defended his fellow councillors “who are trying daily, without remuneration of any kind, to give service to their fellow citizens”.

While Larkin could be difficult to deal with, Joe’s overall assessment was that he was “personally grateful… and intensely proud that he so closely passed my way”.

The Inchicore/Ballyfermot Co-op

Amidst his busy working and political life, Joe found time to be involved in the development of the Inchicore Co-operative. The co-op was initiated by Tim Graham, an old school friend of Joe’s and a fellow member of the Inchicore Branch of the Labour Party.

The co-op set up a grocery shop in Grattan Crescent in Inchicore and, with Joe’s assistance, also got tenancy of a larger shop in Decies Road in Ballyfermot. Following a request from Tim Graham, Joe subsequently took on the position of chairperson.

The co-op was ‘…very successful, we had 700 members and we were able to pay dividends’. It was also hard work, as every weekend members of the co-op committee were out canvassing for members and collecting subscriptions. A few years later a large scale ‘red scare’ controversy was to blow up over the running of this valuable community effort.

If you would like to buy a copy of the full biography please contact either Brian Kenny at kennybj@eircom.net or Eric Byrne at ericbyrn@indigo.ie .

The audio recording where Joe talks about the Ballyfermot Co-op was posted by Conor McCabe in his post Joe Deasy: Irish Marxist on the 27th of November last.

 
 Joe Deasy on the Ballyfermot Co-op: Play Now | Play in Popup | Download

Discussion

We welcome and encourage lively discussion from the public about articles on Irish Left Review. You can leave a comment using the form at the bottom of the page. Please read through the existing comments before posting your own.

No comments so far

This article is, however, being discussed on the following websites:

  1. Feb 21st 2010

Leave a Comment

(required)

(required, will not be published)

Best of the Web

  • Newspaper Circulation Figures

    CIRCULATION FIGURES:
    Jan - June 2010

    Irish Independent 144896
    Irish Examiner 46687
    The Irish Times 105742
    Irish Daily Star 93729
    Irish Daily Mirror 60460
    The Irish Sun 86064
    Irish Daily Mail 51338
    Weekend Herald 40933

    No comments »
  • EAPN Ireland | Workfare Won’t Work for the Unemployed

    Excellent blog post from Aiden Lloyd, on EAPN’s On the Line blog. This pretty much nails the governments ‘thinking’ behind the workfare scheme. It wants to be seen to be doing something, while doing absolutely nothing. The economic structure of the country is based on attracting foreign capital, aka laundering profits, which only really benefits a small minority. Everything else is supposed to ‘trickle down’ from this. They’re not interested in restructuring the economy to boost indiginous growth.

    Minister O’Cuiv aims to use these schemes to provide unemployed people with short-term work activity, to up-skill them and ‘get them back into the mainstream workforce as speedily as possible’. He further contends that ‘maintaining people’s employability through regular work activity will be important for getting people back into the competitive economy’. This stance is revealing and is indicative of government thinking in terms of job creation for unemployed people. It would appear that the decision has already been made that any recovery will be dependent on a general improvement in the global economy and that the immediate priority is to manage matters until this recovery comes about.

    No comments »
  • Hugh Green | Anglo Grinder

    Hugh Green, on foot of the largest profit loss in Irish history - the 8.2 bn lost by Anglo Irish Bank in six months - has started to look at the figures and its eye watering.

    Grants to Enterprise was ticking over nicely all the way through the boom, making up 5-7% of capital expenditure. Then bam! 2009 we’re up to nearly 25% of capital expenditure. Only problem is that in 2009, it’s mostly down to Anglo Irish Bank.

    And

    But seeing as we’re heading into the propaganda season leading up to the budget, talking about the ‘savings’ that will have to be made, what with the ‘fiscal austerity’ being demanded by the ‘markets’, in the form of cuts to welfare, education and health, consider austerity in relation to spending on Anglo Irish Bank.

    See chart for details.

    No comments »
  • Slavefare: government proposal is a sham

    This comment from an anonymous punter on progressive economy sums up many of my thoughts on the matter
    "The thing that annoys me most about this is that it's not a real proposal. The Department can't provide any detailed proposals because there aren't any!

    The Minister appears to have thrown a (bad) idea out there to convey the impression that something's being done to tackle our unemployment problem when the reality couldn't be further from the truth.
    He's accused unemployed people of widespread fraud, without offering them any hope of getting a real job.

    We've seen the biggest recorded job losses in the history of the state, and Minister O'Cuiv thinks the numbers are high because people are refusing jobs, or working and claiming - what jobs does he think are out there? Employers are complaining because they're inundated with applications for any job advertised, not because no-one's applying!

    No comments »
  • Social Europe Needs a New Economic Model | John Palmer at Social Europe Journal

    There is however, a deep issue at stake if defence of decent European social standards is to be placed at the heart of policy making and not to become an increasingly powerless lobby at the margins of the debate. For that to happen the European Union must surely break with an almost exclusive emphasis on GDP as the be all and end all of economic policy objectives. The time has come to replace GDP with a far wider, more socially and environmentally responsible measure of economic progress.

    No comments »
  • Michael Burke’s common on Michael Taft’s post on progressive-economy@tasc re Service exports

    In the late boom year of 2005 the Gross Value Added (GVA) of the building and construction sector was €12.9bn and industry ex bulding was €33.6bn (2009 National incomes and Accounts, Table 4). By contrast the GVA of 'Other services', which includes financial services was €67.6bn.

    If we turn to the separate Input-Output tables, the 3 categories of financial services (finance, insurance and related) comprised €32bn.

    These are very large numbers and they are based on a fiction.

    The CSO link provided by Michael Taft shows Ireland has a trade deficit in services with the US of some €17.4bn, whereas services trade with the Europe and the rest of the world is in surplus.

    1 comment »
  • New Left Project | NLP Blog

    Good post on the BBC's official response to criticism of their Panorama documentary on the Gaza flotilla
    The BBC has, predictably, “dismiss[ed]” claims that a recent Panorama documentary on the Gaza flotilla was biased towards Israel. But its response itself illustrates the crux of the problem:

    “Israel has been accused of breaking international law by seizing a Turkish ship. Israel says they were terrorists. Turkey insists they were innocent victims.”

    That same opposition was proposed throughout the documentary on the flotilla: were the activists terrorists, or were they innocent peace activists?

    No comments »
  • Companies Dodge $60 Billion in Taxes Even Tea Party Condemns - BusinessWeek

    The Double Irish’

    On advice from Ernst & Young, Forest Laboratories Ireland reorganized that year, dropping the country from its name. The newly dubbed Forest Laboratories Holdings Ltd. established a registered office in Hamilton, Bermuda, declaring the island its tax residence. This unit took control of licensing the patents.

    A second subsidiary in Ireland inherited the old name. It handled the manufacturing, sublicensing the rights to the patents, according to a corporate disclosure and an internal Forest flow chart tracing the arrangement that was reviewed by Bloomberg.

    The change helped the Irish subsidiary cut its effective tax rate to 2.4 percent from 10.3 percent the year before the reorganization, according to its annual reports. It did so by deducting from its taxable income the fees that went to Bermuda, which has no corporate income tax. Charlie Perkins, a spokesman for Ernst & Young, one of the so-called Big Four, declined to comment on its work for Forest.

    No comments »
  • Ireland: A recession of the banks, by the banks, and for the banks | afoe | A Fistful of Euros | European Opinion

    And yet it’s not clear that the worst is over. The banks haven’t yet made a big move on distressed home mortgages and no one is clear what will happen when forebearance is no longer a viable strategy. Notwithstanding the government’s attempts to compare tax revenue to “profile” (i.e. a very recent projection), the fact is that tax revenue is stagnant at last year’s depression-like levels despite an apparent recovery in economic statistics. And while there are those desperate hotels, the tourists will still find fussy and expensive restaurants (plus VAT).

    Are there any tricks left in the bag? The government is looking at privatization, most likely as a way to realize a large amount of cash at fairly short notice — essentially a portfolio switch of state-owned companies for all the bank liabilities it has taken on. And there are some bizarre Thatcherite echoes in the possible appearance of a poll tax by the end of the year (dressed up as a “flat rate” water charge or property tax)

    No comments »
  • How Much Did Eurozone States Spend On Bailing Out Private Banks? | Irish Public Policy

    As a percentage of GDP the Euro-area average is 25.4%, the EU 27 is 31.2%. This is about 1,870 billion for the entire Eurozone. Nothing compared to what has been allocated to the Greek government. But, get this, Ireland spent a whopping 231.8% of its GDP, massively above any other country. Most of this is accounted for by the blanket guarantee of bank liabilities.

    No comments »

Link Archives »