Dumb and Dumber at the Sunday Independent
The front page story on the Sunday Independent really says it all. Apparently, the Labour Court has awarded a pay increase to Bord na Mona workers. The Sindo no like. How dare workers get a pay increase? And in this dislike they make some claims which show how dumb some journalism can get when it is caught in an ideological frenzy:
‘The recommendation by the Labour Court, on a broader level, would seem to make a mockery of a claim by the Government that it is getting to grips with the cost of the public sector.’
‘In recent weeks, several government ministers have said the public pay bill needs to be cut so that the country can escape a straitjacket imposed by the EU-IMF.’
‘In other words, the Labour Court does not believe that the economic crisis, which has forced the country to the brink of bankruptcy, is reason enough to impose cuts in public sector pay — let alone block a pay increase.’
This is all very interesting - especially as Bord na Mona pay has absolutely nothing to do with public sector pay. Let me repeat that: Bord na Mona pay has absolutely nothing to do with public sector pay. You could slash workers’ wages by half, pay them in black bread and potato broth, and it would have no impact on the public sector pay bill.
Bord na Mona is a commercial public enterprise. It earns revenue in the marketplace by producing goods and services that people pay for. Out of that it earns profits and pays its workers. It sounds strangely like a private enterprise company; that’s because it is.
While its core business is the supply of peat as a fuel for electricity generation, it is also developing biomass and renewable energy. It is a solution provider in wastewater treatment and air pollution abatement systems. It manufactures and supplies media products for the horticultural market. It is involved in the collection and environmental treatment of waste. And sells into the domestic and export markets.
It does a good job. It earns nearly €400 million a year with an operating profit of €23 million, handing over €30 million in dividends to the state in the last four years. It has a strong profit margin of 18 percent (earnings before interest, depreciation, taxes and amortisation).
It employs over 2,000 workers directly - increasing their payroll by 100 in the last two years of the recession. But, of course, considerably more are employed, sourcing into Bord na Mona; all of these are in the private sector.
These are not the highest-paid public or private enterprise workers - far from it; less than an average €45,000 per employee. And since 2005, employees’ compensation has fallen from nearly 40 percent of total revenue to less than 30 percent. Indeed, Bord na Mona workers appear quite productive. Since 2002, company revenue earned per employee increased by over 55 percent.
So why is the Sindo attacking a profitable company which, albeit under a Labour Court recommendation, is paying a wage increase to productive workers in a commercial enterprise that sells into the domestic and export market?
Is it because they’re a tad confused - thinking that any company with the word ‘public’ in it pays their workers out of the Exchequer? If so, here is a hint to Sindo editors: a ‘public limited company‘ is not part of the public sector.
This is all pretty dumb. But here’s where it gets dumber. What would happen if the Sindo got its way and the Bord na Mona workers don’t get a pay increase? Who would be the losers? Broadly speaking, there would be three losers.
First, of course, are the workers themselves and their families.
Second are local businesses that are dependent on the spending power of Bord na Mona workers. Given that the workers are average paid, they are likely to spend a disproportionate amount. Of course, they could use some of those extra earnings to get out of arrears or even save a bit. But it’s not likely they have accounts with Japanese hedge funds. This is a spending group.
The third loser is the Exchequer. Anywhere from 31 to 52 percent of the extra income goes directly to the Exchequer before it gets into the workers’ pockets. That doesn’t count the extra revenue from increased spending (VAT) nor increased employers’ PRSI.
From the reported 3.5 percent pay increase being awarded, using the State Assets report average pay finding, the Exchequer would benefit between €646 and €983 per employee. For the entire workforce, the Exchequer could benefit by up €1.5 million and more. That’s what comes from a successful and profitable company paying its employees more.
So what have we got? A major national newspaper that doesn’t know the difference between a commercial enterprise and the public sector. And from that basic ignorance, they demand a policy that will depress living standards, depress private sector activity and depress Exchequer revenue - a policy that will ensure we remain mired in recession.
You really couldn’t make this stuff up.
Discussion
We welcome and encourage lively discussion from the public about articles on Irish Left Review. You can leave a comment using the form at the bottom of the page. Please read through the existing comments before posting your own.
Comment by: Des Derwin
May 16th 2011 at 12:05
Great work Michael! This is the kind of demolishing counterattack that boosts our morale.
Comment by: tom
May 16th 2011 at 13:05
Of course, when we say that you couldn’t make it up it is important to note that the Sunday Independent did just that: they made it up.
Though the truth is that what has passed for media analysis over the last 3 years is so bad that it is beyond satire, it is also true that that is all that most people read. Many don’t even read it, they just half listen to radio discussions among so-called experts who refer to their own articles to bolster their ill founded arguments.
And they so dominate the media that they are winning.
Comment by: William Wall
May 16th 2011 at 13:05
Sometimes it looks like they get Brendan O’Connor to write their news for them. As you say, ideologically driven nonsense, but it supports the discourse of blaming the Public service for everything.