Leave it out!  Left in and left out in Irish Syrizian thinking


50 Flares Twitter 0 Facebook 50 50 Flares ×
Print pagePDF pageEmail page

The imminent truncation of the Labour Party and the rise of Sinn Féin would probably have tabled it anyway. But the reaction to Syriza’s election in Greece has changed the topography of the Irish left unity discussion (such as it is) in one long political week.  Not necessarily for the better. Sinn Féin and then SIPTU President Jack O’Connor , and others,  have shifted the frame from a radical left alliance to one effectively taking in Sinn Féin and even Labour.

These two propositions are very different animals altogether. Furthermore, in a burst of ‘yeah, let’s do it too’ élan, people are now talking about going for a left government. The strewn constellation of the radical left will likely be split on the wider of the projects, even if it gets no further than a talking point. Including even a shrunken Labour is almost a no-no for the radical left. Including Sinn Féin is highly problematical to say the least. (Some categorise them outside the left; the anti water charge campaign left their left flank exposed, and may still do; two recent developments raised leftist eyebrows that may not have been raised before: the cutback provisions of the Stormont House Agreement and their failure to support Clare Daly’s December Bill to repeal the constitutional ban on abortion).

But here is another problem. Sinn Féin’s stature as a left party does not depend on how they are viewed by one or other far left party, but on how they are viewed by the electorate (voting workers, blue and white collared). It will be very difficult to carry an argument for a united left alternative while simultaneously arguing that it should exclude Sinn Féin (and arguing for a similar exclusion with those who would want to add Labour too).

Fortunately there is an old shepherd’s crook on the Irish left for separating the sheep from the goats: coalition with conservative parties (effectively Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael). If this condition is raised by the radical left it requires Sinn Féin (and Labour) to qualify their political positioning, and rescues the radical left from the accusation of refusing to unite for a ‘left alternative’ offered (with various degrees of sincerity) to the people. So, there is a simple question for Sinn Féin, Jack O’Connor and others. Would a vote for Sinn Féin or Labour be guaranteed as a vote for the left? Or could it end up as a vote for another coalition led by, or with a large bloc from, Fianna Fáil or Fine Gael? How do you stand – now – on such a coalition? Of course there are crucial policy and programmatic matters to be considered. But this initial question would indicate whether there really is any game on at all.


4 Responses

  1. frank peters

    February 3, 2015 12:59 pm

    Yes, very important. While Syriza builds a coalition of the left and then (justifiably) goes into with Independent Greeks, it’s crucial here to find reasons no to go into with Sinn Féin. That way the posturing of the Irish ‘radical left’, can never have to be put to the test. Safest bet.

  2. Roger Cole

    February 4, 2015 3:06 pm

    Syriza gained power because of its ability to achieve unity among a diverse range of left groups and then form a coalition with a Greek nationalist party. If the Fianna Fail / Fine Gael block are to be defeated then the Irish left have to develop the same ability to build a unity between a range of left groups and go into coalition with an Irish nationalist party

  3. Des Derwin

    February 15, 2015 12:24 pm

    Sinn Féin is the biggest party in the latest opinion poll. Independents and others down. Sinn Féin is getting the Syriza factor, even directly from Syriza itself. Paul Murphy (and the gains of many other outstanding and valiant campaigners) notwithstanding, the radical left is missing the election boat. But a new left party, or a strong slate at least, will help it stand its ground and even improve its position substantially. Meanwhile the radical left will need to find a way to relate to Sinn Féin’s (and perhaps several trade unions’) unitary or ‘left government’ overtures in a way that avoids the possibility of leaving itself squeezed or even isolated. An overwhelming Sinn Féin wave may be unavoidable in the next election anyway. Followed even by the unavoidable historical lesson of a government including or even dominated by Sinn Féin.

  4. Des Derwin

    February 15, 2015 12:55 pm

    Just now my attention has been drawn to this – kinda historical when you think of it – statement from the Right2Water trade unions, proposing an agreed platform before the next election: http://www.mandate.ie/News/Mandate/1093/right2water-unions-to-present-platform-for-renewal-to-may-day-conference-in-dublin.aspx

    A side point, for trade unionists in particular, is the evolution of a shadow Congress within the movement. Or, at the least, a continuing source of worry to those of us in SIPTU especially who grieve for the isolation of our Union from the greatest working class movement (on water charges) since the tax marches. And now, it seems, so far, isolation from this very significant – and essentially left wing – political initiative from five trade unions, four of them major organisations and one of them headed by the current President of the ICTU.